Not every thrifted furniture find comes without a few flaws, but that doesn’t mean it can’t become something beautiful! Sometimes, those little dings and scratches are the perfect opportunity to get creative.
Today, we’re welcoming Denise from Salvaged Inspirations back to the Dixie Belle blog! She’s sharing a clever way to disguise furniture imperfections while adding beautiful texture and detail. With a raised stencil and a classic black finish, she gives an imperfect thrift store dresser a whole new look.
Let’s see how she brings this piece back to life!
(The following is an excerpt from Salvaged Inspirations. Read the full article here.)
This thrift store tallboy was the perfect blank canvas to get creative with… except it wasn’t exactly perfect. It had plenty of little imperfections, repairs, and flat surfaces that needed some help.
Even while I was cleaning, sanding, and priming, I had NO idea where this makeover was going. But I’ve learned that’s okay. Sometimes you just have to START. Action always seems to spark more ideas than sitting there and staring at a piece. And eventually, the idea came — raised stencils!
I’ve been using this technique on furniture since 2015, and it’s such an easy way to add texture and character to plain furniture. But on this dresser, the raised stencil had another job too… disguising all those little flaws and imperfections.
Here’s how this imperfect thrift store tallboy came together!
Here’s the Tallboy Dresser I found at my local Mission Thrift Store. It was structurally sound with great bones but had a bunch of small dings, holes, and scratches all over it.

SUPPLIES
Mission Tallboy Dresser – SALVAGED
White Lightning Cleaner
Auto Sponge
DeWalt Impact Gun Drill Set
Palm Sander For Scuff Sanding
Sanding Sponge
Bonding BOSS Primer
Royal Damask Stencil Design
Brown Mud For Raised Stencil
4″ Roller for Primer
2″ Angled Paint Brush
Anchor Black Silk Mineral Paint
Gator Hide Topcoat
PREPPING THE DRESSER FOR ITS MAKEOVER
To start prepping, I removed the hardware using my DeWalt Impactor and then gave this dresser a super good cleaning with my heavy-duty furniture cleaner and a large automotive sponge. Then I let the dresser dry overnight.

PRIMING & PAINTING
Once I had all the drawers cleaned and the body and top scuff sanded as well, I removed all the dust and brought it back into my paint room for some stain-blocking primer. At this point I still had NO idea what I was going to do with the piece, but I figured I’d get the primer on there and at least solve the bleed-through issue (and see what needed filling/fixing) before I decided on colors, design, etc. It’s also a great way to SEE all the dings and scratches that need filling. For this dresser, there were so many of them it would have been quite the patch job!

HOW TO HIDE IMPERFECTIONS AND MATCH UP A RAISED STENCIL DESIGN
Raised stencilling is easy to do and it doesn’t have to be perfect because once its painted and or sanded back, the imperfections are what create interest and texture!
- Start by picking your stencil design to compliment the furniture your working with.
- Center the stencil on your furniture or pick the placement you like and then use some tape to keep the stencil in place.
- Using some Mud or texture on a putty knife, smooth the medium over the stencil design.
- Scrape the excess medium off the surface of the stencil and then lift the stencil carefully to reveal the embossed design.
- Let your raised stencil design dry and then go ahead and paint it, gild it, distress it, or whatever finishing technique you like!
With such a large area to cover in a raised stencil design, I needed to stencil and then reposition the stencil to continue the design.
Matching a stencil pattern is so much easier when it’s dry or semi-dry!
It was much easier to lay the stencil overtop and maneuver it without worrying about messing up what you’ve already stenciled. Once I found the perfect match, I added the Mud to the rest of the drawer top.
Tips – I used an inexpensive plastic drywall putty knife to spread out the mud and scrape off the excess. I found this really helped the drying process go much faster. And then using my heat gun to dry it a little more before matching up the design was very helpful as well.

PAINTING IN TRADITIONAL BLACK
It’s time to paint! To give this dresser a traditional look, I chose to paint it in a classic black. The damask design is very traditional, so I thought it would be the perfect match. This dresser took two coats for full coverage. I used my brush-and-roll paint technique for a SUPER SMOOTH finish. You can see the full step-by-step + video brush-and-roll technique here.
To apply this paint, I used my synthetic DB short brush, and then used this 4inch roller to smooth everything out. If you’re not set up with a paint gun, I believe this is the BEST way to get as close to a brush-free spray finish without using a sprayer.

Below is a close-up of how smooth the roller evens out the paint. This is still wet, and once this wet paint self-levels, it looks flawless!

FINISHING TOUCHES WITH TOPCOAT
Because I used Anchor Black All-In-One Silk Paint, a topcoat is NOT required. But to make it look more elegant and increase the sheen a little, I sprayed 2 coats of Gator Hide.
Pro Tip ~ You can apply a gloss OVER the raised stencil to increase the sheen and bring more attention to the embossed design as I did on these nightstands here. It’s really easy to do. I keep my paintbrush at a low angle to the stencil and just kiss the raised stencil while brushing across the raised design. The key is not overloading the paintbrush. You want it fairly dry because you don’t want the topcoat dripping onto the flat surface.

THE BIG REVEAL…
Here’s the finished look! What do you think!?

And here’s a closer look at the side view and the painted pulls. I’m really glad I top-coated to add the little extra sheen.

I think this dresser is perfectly imperfect and looks very elegant!

Here’s another look at this thrifted tallboy dresser before and after.

What a beautiful reminder that furniture doesn’t have to be perfect to deserve a second chance! We love how Denise used a raised stencil to turn those little imperfections into an opportunity for something creative.
A big thank you to Denise from Salvaged Inspirations for sharing this gorgeous makeover with us!





